The Best Mild Cigars for Beginners (Chosen by Actual Tobacconists)
The fastest way to ruin a new smoker's first cigar is to hand them something dark, strong and expensive. The right first cigars are mild, creamy, well-made and forgiving - flavorful enough to be interesting, gentle enough to enjoy to the band. These are the ones we actually hand to beginners at our counters.
1. Rocky Patel Vintage 1999
Connecticut shade wrapper aged seven years makes the Vintage 1999 buttery-smooth with toasted almond and cream. Excellent construction means an easy draw - a beginner's most underrated feature.
2. Arturo Fuente Flor Fina 8-5-8
The 8-5-8 is mild-to-medium, silky, and one of the best values in premium cigars, period. It's also the cigar Carlos Fuente Sr. chose for himself - you're in good company.
3. The Edge Connecticut by Rocky Patel
Golden, creamy and priced for practice - the Edge Connecticut lets you learn to cut, light and pace yourself without wincing at the cost.
4. Hemingway Short Story
Only forty minutes, gorgeous to look at, and mild-to-medium with natural Cameroon sweetness - the Short Story is the single most gifted cigar in our shops.
5. La Flor de Dulzura Connecticut
Our own King Corona Exclusive, grown for us and sold nowhere else - 5-packs from $49.99. Smooth and easygoing, and once you find your favorite, the box of 20 is the best value in our humidor.
Three beginner mistakes to skip
- Smoking too fast. One puff every 45 - 60 seconds keeps the cigar cool and sweet.
- Inhaling. Cigars are tasted, not inhaled - flavor lives on the palate.
- Starting with a "strong" recommendation. Strength is earned, not assigned.
Want it even easier? Walk into any of our four stores and say "it's my first cigar." That sentence gets our staff genuinely excited. Or browse everything mild here.
Shop the humidor
100+ premium cigars - Arturo Fuente, Rocky Patel and our exclusive Dulzura Farms - shipped fresh from our humidor.
Shop All Cigars Browse Samplers